8
Manuscripts
Released in 1979 through 2023
1
Manuscript
Impact studies rated high or moderate quality
Skip to: Effectiveness Implementation
Where to find out more
National Service Office for Nurse-Family Partnership and Child First
1801 California St., Suite 2400, Denver, CO 80202
This model meets criteria established by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services for an evidence-based home visiting model.
Does not meet criteria for an evidence-based home visiting model for Indigenous peoples and communities.
For more information about manuscripts, search the research database.
For more information on the criteria used to rate research, please see details of HomVEEʼs methods and standards.
8
Manuscripts
Released in 1979 through 2023
1
Manuscript
Eligible for review
1
Manuscript
Impact studies rated high or moderate quality
To see details on each manuscript HomVEE reviewed in well-designed research, click on the manuscript counts in the table.
Favorable:
A finding showing a statistically significant impact on an outcome measure in a direction that is beneficial for children and parents.
No effect:
Findings are not statistically significant.
Unfavorable:
A finding showing a statistically significant impact on an outcome measure in a direction that may indicate potential harm to children and/or parents.
| Outcomes | Manuscripts | Favorable Findings | No Effects Findings | Unfavorable Findings |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Child development and school readiness | View 1 Manuscript | 5 | 11 | 0 |
| Child health | Not measured | - | - | - |
| Family economic self-sufficiency | Not measured | - | - | - |
| Linkages and referrals | View 1 Manuscript | 11 | 0 | 0 |
| Maternal health | View 1 Manuscript | 11 | 15 | 0 |
| Positive parenting practices | Not measured | - | - | - |
| Reductions in child maltreatment | Not measured | - | - | - |
| Reductions in juvenile delinquency, family violence, and crime | Not measured | - | - | - |
Well-designed impact studies about this model included participants with the following characteristics:
Race/Ethnicity
Maternal Education
Well-designed impact studies about this model were conducted in the following locations:
In this section:
Support Availability
Service Delivery
Model services, adaptions and enhancements, model intensity and length.
Child First partners with pregnant people and families with infants and young children to enhance strong, loving relationships. The program uses a relationship-focused, two-generation infant/early childhood mental health model. The model intentionally considers structural inequities experienced by families as well as the impact of past and present trauma, such as historical trauma, oppression, and structural racism. Child First aims to support caregivers and their children by helping them process the stresses and trauma in their lives and enhancing healthy patterns of interactions between a caregiver and a child. Child First strives to intervene with families as early as possible and to connect them to services and supports within their communities to help ease their stress.
The Child First intervention was developed as a two-pronged approach:
Child First uses a team-based approach to home visiting involving a mental health clinician and a care coordinator. This team approach offers (1) two independent observations, especially during the assessment phase (first 4 to 8 weeks of the intervention); (2) multiple perspectives, which can aid in understanding the family; (3) a model for families on how two adults communicate and cooperate; (4) peer support for the home visitors to help lessen any vicarious trauma they may experience; and (5) continuation and consistency of work with the family (within their own roles) when one team member is unavailable.
Child First serves pregnant people and families with children from birth through age 5 in which (1) children have emotional, behavioral, or developmental difficulties or (2) the family faces multiple environmental and psychosocial challenges, such as caregiver depression, domestic violence, substance use, insecure housing, or abuse and neglect, that could contribute to negative parent and child outcomes. Child First views these environmental and psychosocial challenges as social determinants of health. Families are served without regard for their legal status or the number of children in the family.
Child First seeks to prevent and decrease a family’s involvement with child protective services and improve a child’s behavior, social skills, and communication. Child First also seeks to prevent and reduce depressive and post-traumatic stress disorder symptoms and decrease parenting stress for caregivers. The model also aims to improve the child-caregiver relationship and increase the family’s connection to community-based services.
Highlights
Child First is supported by the National Service Office (NSO) for Nurse-Family Partnership and Child First. The NSO is a nonprofit organization based in Colorado that supports model implementation throughout the Child First network, which is composed of local providers known as Child First affiliate agencies. The NSO provides these affiliate agencies with implementation guidance, ongoing training, clinical consultation, and technical assistance. It also provides data support, analysis, and access to reports on process and outcome data to support implementation fidelity and quality improvement.
Each state or region with affiliate agencies is supported by a clinical lead who is a member of the Child First team at the NSO. This individual (1) provides affiliate agencies in the state or region with clinical and administrative oversight, technical assistance, and biweekly clinical consultation; (2) coordinates with Child First network development and government affairs staff to support affiliate agency leadership; and (3) supports integrating the Child First model into local and state early childhood systems of care.
Affiliate agencies can request technical assistance from the NSO to support model implementation throughout the course of their active contract period.
Highlights
Child First is a home-based psychotherapeutic intervention. Child First services are provided by a team consisting of a mental health clinician and a care coordinator. The team comprehensively assesses a child’s and family’s needs and supports the family through both joint and individual sessions depending on identified needs. The major intervention components include the following:
Various therapeutic intervention strategies to best fit the family’s needs. Staff are trained in a range of early childhood psychotherapeutic approaches that can be integrated into sessions depending on family dynamics. The team works to support and strengthen the relationship between the caregiver and child to optimize early relational health for young children and families who have experienced trauma and adversity.
Comprehensive, reflective care coordination to address primary needs. The care coordinator addresses (1) acute family stressors, such as insecure housing, lack of heat or food, expulsion from child care, or imminent removal of the child from the home; (2) a broad range of chronic challenges related to the social determinants of health, such as caregiver depression, domestic violence, substance use, insecure housing, or abuse and neglect; and (3) connection to growth-promoting, community-based services and supports.
Metacognitive strategies to support executive functioning skills in both caregiver and child. Executive functioning encompasses the capacity to organize, plan, and prepare for activities as well as to regulate one’s emotions while engaged in tasks. Emotional regulation is a core component of executive functioning that is modeled and supported by both team members. The care coordinator uses scaffolding as they support the caregiver in the development of other executive functioning capacities. As part of this, the care coordinator works with the caregiver to develop individual and family goals, prioritize needs and goals, create step-by-step plans to accomplish them, monitor and reflect on progress, and revise those plans as needed. The care coordinator also shares with the family an interactive, relationship-based approach (based on the Abecedarian Approach) to games and activities, language and reading, and routines and caregiving. This approach is designed to promote the caregiver-child relationship and child self-regulation and cognitive ability.
Mental health consultation in early care settings. When consent is provided, a clinician or clinical team observes the child within their early care setting, such as a formal early care and education center or home-based child care. As part of the assessment process, the team gathers information about the child’s strengths and any behavioral or emotional concerns from the teachers or child care providers. Child First then works with the teacher or child care provider depending on the child’s need and the availability of other mental health consultants working in that setting. Child First fully collaborates with other mental health providers so as not to duplicate services.
The NSO expects the team to provide a majority of services within the home or a mutually agreed upon community setting. The team may provide virtual visits when deemed appropriate and permissible by state or other funding regulations, particularly as visits relate to individual therapeutic sessions with caregivers or assisting families to meet their basic needs through care coordination or both.
During the assessment phase (first four to eight weeks of the intervention), the Child First team strives to visit families together twice per week. The clinician also visits the families alone to inquire about child and adult trauma.
After that phase, the clinician and care coordinator may visit the family together or separately, depending on the unique needs of the child and family. Visits are a minimum of once per week but could happen several times per week, if needed. They typically last 60 to 90 minutes, depending on circumstances. Services are provided from 6 to 12 months but could be longer, depending on family needs.
Because of the flexible nature of its delivery, Child First has not yet developed allowable deviations from the model. However, doing so may be necessary depending on new settings and new populations, such as Tribal communities. Child First is willing to explore adaptations and enhancements through an intentional process grounded in understanding population needs, planning implementation accordingly, and conducting pilot projects to assess needed modifications.
Highlights
A team consisting of a mental health clinician and a care coordinator work together to deliver the intervention. A Child First–trained clinical director or supervisor provides reflective clinical and administrative supervision for each team. An affiliate agency must have a senior clinician to provide reflective, clinical supervision and implementation support to the affiliate site’s Child First clinical director or supervisor.
Child First teams must be culturally informed and sensitive and meet the language needs of the communities served. Child First requires staff to have the following education and experience:
The Child First clinical director or supervisor provides each clinician and care coordinator with a total of 3.5 hours of clinical, reflective supervision per week: 1 hour of individual supervision, 1 hour of clinical team (clinician and care coordinator together) supervision, and 1.5 to 2.0 hours of group supervision with all teams together. All staff receive programmatic or administrative supervision as a group for at least one hour per month. Clinical directors or supervisors must also maintain an open-door policy to respond to acute clinical needs.
During the first year of implementation, the state or regional clinical lead provides on-site weekly reflective clinical consultation with new affiliates, including individual consultation with the affiliate site clinical director or supervisor and group consultation with all Child First teams. After 12 months, the state or regional clinical lead provides the affiliate site clinical director or supervisor with individual consultation biweekly for another year, after which time consultation support varies depending on need. The affiliate site clinical directors or supervisors also participate in Child First Clinical Director Network Meetings, which occur monthly.
The model requires staff to participate in foundational training delivered through distance learning modules and an in-person, on-site Child First Learning Collaborative. Child First provides foundational training in infant and early childhood mental health, including topics such as development, attachment, trauma, adversity, social determinants of health, physical health, adult mental health and substance use, early diagnosis, executive functioning, reflective process, and the Abecedarian Approach. The Child First NSO provides all new clinical directors or supervisors with an intensive preservice training centered around the principles of diversity-informed reflective supervision as it relates to the Child First model. Please contact the model developer for additional information about the preservice training requirement and any ongoing professional development requirements.
The NSO works with state and community stakeholders to select Child First affiliate agencies in a region. Affiliate agencies must be or have the following qualifications:
This model requires affiliate agencies and staff to meet a set of ongoing fidelity guidelines. Please contact the model developer for additional information about these guidelines.
Highlights
HomVEE requests input and feedback from the model developers on their profiles. The information in this implementation profile reflects feedback, if provided, from this model’s developer as of the above date. HomVEE reserves the right to edit the profile for clarity and consistency. The description of the implementation of the model(s) here may differ from how the model(s) was implemented in the manuscripts reviewed to determine this model’s evidence of effectiveness. Model developers are encouraged to notify HomVEE of any changes to their contact information on this page.